November 27, 2012
Quebec inquiry wanders into exclusive club where construction meetings were held
Quebec's corruption inquiry has crept inside one of Montreal's most exclusive establishments where members of the political and construction worlds came to eat and meet.
Club 357c is a high-end, members-only establishment located at that address on de la Commune Street, in the heart of Old Montreal.
What went on at that posh club, which was a frequent meeting point for construction bosses, engineers and elected officials?
Late Tuesday, an investigator began walking the inquiry through a list of people who met there. That prompted a memorable flareup - when the lawyer for the Quebec Liberals attempted to have a temporary publication ban slapped on the identity of two party members who met there.
A visibly annoyed Justice France Charbonneau began scolding the lawyer, her voice rising at his unexpected late-day request. She was pleased when he later agreed to drop that request, on the guarantee that the Liberals' names would not come out before Wednesday.
"Now there's an offer I can't refuse."Charbonneau deadpanned.
The club itself, where annual membership fees are reportedly about $3,500, is of no interest to Quebec's corruption inquiry, commission counsel Denis Gallant said Tuesday. What does matter, however, is the written record of meetings held in those lavish surroundings.
There were only two ways to gain access - you had to be a member or be invited by a member. And all of it was documented, Gallant said, because the club kept meticulous logs of who came and went to the establishment through sign-in sheets.
The records even note what people ate and drank.
The inquiry has been hearing sensational testimony about widespread corruption in Quebec's construction industry that saw the price of public works contracts skyrocket thanks to collusion and bid-rigging. The illicit spoils were allegedly divided between political parties, construction companies, the Mafia and a handful of crooked civil servants.
The testimony has already led to the resignation of the mayors of Montreal and neighbouring Laval.
Many of the names that have been heard this fall were listed as club patrons. The inquiry has not alleged anything illegal went on at the club - simply that certain people met there.
An earlier witness, onetime loanshark and construction industry insider Elio Pagliarulo, previously testified that he made cash drops at the exclusive club for Frank Zampino - the former No. 2 at the City of Montreal who now faces fraud charges.
The club caught the attention of investigators last month and they decided to pay it a visit, said Erick Roy, a lead investigator for the commission.
The club issued a statement promising its full co-operation. The club has had 1,000 members in its decade in existence and they invited numerous other guests, the statement said.
"The 357c has collaborated voluntarily with the Commission and supplied the requested information," it said.
"It's important to note that ever since its opening the 357c states clearly in its rules that it will co-operate entirely with all legitimate legal body if there's an investigation into a club member.... It would be unfortunate and unacceptable if the actions of a very small minority of 357c clients had a negative effect on the image of the club and its members."
The inquiry only finished Tuesday examining the first of about 10 pages of meetings _ held between 2005 and 2006 _ and it will continue going through the pages Wednesday.
The first page included about a dozen names.
Among those who attended meetings at the club were high-ranking executives with engineering firms; a former Union Montreal fundraiser; the city's former No. 2 politician, Frank Zampino; and the former mayor of a central borough.
They included Frank Zampino, the former head of Montreal's powerful executive committee; Bernard Trepanier, a fundraiser for Union Montreal dubbed in local media as "Mr. Three Per Cent"; and Luc Leclerc, a former municipal civil servant who has testified about taking bribes.
The meetings were often convened by Paolo Catania, head of F. Catania Construction, Bernard Poulin, head of engineering firm S.M. Group International, or Pasquale Fidele, president of Civbec who was an senior official at F. Catania.
The inquiry has heard testimony about tight links between the Catania business empire and the most senior figures in the Rizzuto crime family.
People who convened the meetings invited senior executives at engineering firms like Desseau, Genius (formally known as Seguin) or Cima +.
News from © Canadian Press Enterprises Inc., 2012
|MOST POPULAR STORIES|
- Construction begins on 1.5-kilometre western portion of Mississauga transitway
- “Super beam” installed in Montreal Champlain Bridge repair
- Tunnelling of the Toronto-York Spadina Subway Extension completed
- Concrete awards recognize Ontario’s best
- RCMP make another arrest in connection with its SNC-Lavalin probe
- 20 Most Popular Stories
|TODAY’S TOP CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS|
These projects have been selected from 331 projects with a total value of $3,875,502,154 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Monday.
$2,200,000,000 Toronto ON Prebid
$125,000,000 Scarborough ON Prebid
$49,900,000 Toronto ON Prebid
- Toronto firms tops for Winnipeg hut designs
- Toronto architect releases music album
- Road pricing an effective congestion fighter, say experts
- What does “Local Knowledge” really mean in Ontario AFPs?
- United States construction employers add 17,000 jobs in November but growth is uneven, finds AGC
- Toronto housing starts dip: CMHC
- Active unions needed, says Segal
- Saint John Harbour Bridge project wraps up
- New Westminster Development
- Natural gas generating facilities planned
- Refinery costs jump by $2.8 billion
- Employers must be aware of liability at holiday office parties
- New charges needed for infrastructure
- Skills Training at BCIT
- Auditor generals weigh in on value of P3s
- Low lead requirements kicking in next year
- Mental heath and workplace psychology must be addressed
- Edmonton International Airport mall takes shape
- University of Winnipeg building an apartment complex